
In the truest definition of the word it means "one who stays with".
As Paige shared there are a number of these children living in our neighborhood. We are in an area that would be considered middle class - or as close to it as you'll find.
Most folks in our neighborhood did not inherit a bunch of money, nor are they descendants of the upper class French "bourgeois". Most own a small business and work hard to have a larger home in a more secure neighborhood. All of these working class have relatives, acquaintances and friends in the poorer mountain villages and out in the provinces.
The poor send their children in to work for the less poor. They figure their kids might get to eat more, possibly go to school. They often send them out of desperation. Sometimes they just cannot deal with their own children, so they send them away.
These children are easy to pick out. Usually when we see them they are working. Most of them do not appear to be as well taken care of as the other children living in their home. The girls will often have very short hair and be plain looking, giving them less self esteem. They speak quietly and keep their heads down.
Paige shared with you that she was thrilled that one little girl who is a restavek has been coming to her Kids Club and has even been allowed to come for some tutoring. We've felt at a loss when we think about her and are feeling a burden for her. She does not make eye contact when we talk to her. The people she lives with openly call her stupid and dull. She washes dishes and sweeps for them. They say that they "tried to send her to school, but she was too afraid and just cried". We are uncertain of how true that story is, but we do know that a child who believes they are stupid would not do well in school. The people she lives with offered her to us. Literally they said, "She is a hard worker, you can have her if you want."
You. can. have. her.
My God.
My stomach turns when I think about a valuable human being, created in the image of God, being treated this way. I want to scream, I want to lay down and cry, I want to fix it.
I am a foreigner learning about a new culture. Three years here has not taught me enough to confidently say much. I try very hard not to jump to conclusions about things or judge harshly. I cannot possibly understand everything that happens in this culture, it is not my own.
Having said that, this "system" might be one of the most frustrating ones of all for me to accept. The fact that children are used for labor and for the benefit of adults is beyond incomprehensible. There are occasions wherein the child benefits from this arrangement. But that seems to be more the exception than the rule.
[As an aside for adoptive parents. In general adoption is misunderstood. In this culture, if you take someone's child, it is so they can work for you. A lot of people will assume that is also why you are adopting. Jeronne recently told us that once everyone in LaDigue saw how kind we were to our Haitian children, they wanted to know if we would help with their children. We hope that our love and equal treatment of our kids will be evident when we're out and about in Port. Troy noticed a lady at a store observing his shopping with Hope. She later said to him, "You really love her, don't you!?!?!" She was surprised by it and pleased.]
This is a very well done piece about the system, I encourage you to read it.
I quote the author:
"I want to acknowledge that there are families in Haiti that do welcome children into their homes with the primary purpose being to care for the children and promote their well-being. However, in the case of the restavèk system, the main reason the child is in the home is to work. It is not for the sake of the child; it is for the sake of the child’s masters. Today in Haiti, at least one in ten children does everything for free – getting up long before dawn, going to bed (on the floor) long after dark, doing all of the work of the house in the hours in between."
Here is another opinion piece.
And from others living here, read this.
In a recent comment, someone asked us what a restavek is.
I wish we did not know.
2 hours ago



26 comments:
She is beautiful. Is she the same girl in both pictures? My eyes are filled with tears. Will she stay with you? I'm sorry for the questions but this child pierces my heart. Can she be adopted? My Grandmother would have been considered a child slave here in the US. She worked for her keep and took care of the families other children even though she was only about 10. Her mother died and her Father was a drunk so she lived with a family who put her to work...oh the stories she would tell me. They wouldn't allow her to go to school. My heart aches for these children in this situation.
Can this child be adopted? Terry
How heartbreaking.
To know is to be changed.
A horror that is incomprehensible.
May God's hand rest on this child.
HI Terry-
This is very complicated. My head spins as I consider it. So, forgive me if this is disjointed ...
It is doubtful that her family wants her to leave Haiti. In order to be legally adopted you have to have abandonment papers. If you don't have those you need to prove the parents are dead. If you cannot do that it is not likely going to pass by at the end stages of the adoption - especially under ever stricter laws and UNICEF pressure - there has to be a paper trail. There has to be understanding that the child will leave and maybe never come back. Taking a child in when that is not understood and agreed to by the birth family is a slippery slope.
There are 300,000 + of these kids out there.
If we were to take her -- we would open up a giant Pandora's box.
What about the next kid? And the next? What if we leave Haiti? What happens to her then? What if there are underlying motives for the offer? What are the greater ramifications for taking in a child that someone "gives" you. What if she is taken back. Could we be sued? Could we be set up to be falsely accused. What if what if what if. (I know that it might sound over the top - but you learn to live under the assumption that nothing is as it appears.)
Then there are the practical questions -- do we have the ability to help her - what sort of help does she need to heal - would it be better for her -- can we afford another child - can we send her to the same school our kids go to - would we be able to sustain her to adulthood - is there wisdom in that?
And that is the short list. :(
I do not think that any of us feel peace about any of it -- both options are hugely terrible. We feel up to our ears in responsibility. We are grieved by this situation ... and even more grieved to realize it is just one story out of thousands.
As long as the culture accepts it or looks the other way = it will continue.
For now we will love Nehemie (not Leme as originally thought) when we are given the opportunity to do so. We will invite her over and offer her a break from her real life. We will pray for her.
And I know you'll do the same.
I hope I don't sound defensive -- it is not so much that as it is just feeling at a loss and discouraged ...
tara
ps- No - the photos are of two different girls. The girl with Paige is Nehemie and is 9 and washes dishes and sweeps for a family in our neighborhood.
oh my, i can not even formulate my thoughts to leave a comment.
oh Lord be near to this precious child of Your's. Wrap your arms of love around each of these children. Surround them with your love and draw them into a personal relationship with you, where they find their identity in Christ alone. Oh God, you know these children and you love them deeply. Please continue to use Paige to be the hands and feet of Jesus to this girl. Through your Holy Spirit within Paige speak words of wisdom, love, and peace into this sweet girl's heart. Use each of the Livesay's to further your kingdom. Bless their ministries in abundant ways. Encourage their hearts as they serve you. Empower them through Your Holy Spirit. Oh God, I thank you for all the ways you are using them in Haiti! Show each of us what we can do for the lives of these children.
Yes, I did figure all those things as I was asking the question. I was actually asking about adoption, not for your family, but for ours. I've been praying about adopting again. An older child. We are adopting a 2 year old boy from Haiti and are waiting for 2nd legal. I'm afraid to adopt from Haiti because we have 3 bio children(although they are grown). But my heart aches so much for these kids. Especially the older ones.
Could you please email me about Heartline Ministries...are you still involved?
jonesy4him@comcast.net Terry
I have read about and heard stories of the restaveks in Haiti through my parents who currently live in Port au prince. A few years agot there was a 3 yr old restavek living near the mission and they tried to keep an eye on her and visit her. When they told me about her and the sad life she lived my heart immediately wanted to go to Haiti and bring her to a place where she would be loved and be able to have a happy childhood. I looked into international adoptions and started asking questions about her origion and just feeling out the possibilities. We , at the time, din't meet the age requirement for adopting from Haiti anyway. A short time later we found out she had caught fire while making the fire for cooking food or cleaning the coals or something and had died shortly after. It broke my heart that she lived such a sad short and tragic life. I guess she did go to a place of perfect love and joy afterall.
There is so much in Haiti to break a persons heart. Each of those people and children are precious and have immeasurable value in our Heavenly fathers eyes. I know child slavery breaks Gods heart.
God Bless you for shining a light in a dark and desperate place.
for anyone who is interested, the Mennonite Central Committee (MCC) partners with a Haitian organization which does outreach to restavek children in a poor area of Port-au-Prince.
when I lived in Haiti, I had a couple friends who worked with this group, spending afternoons playing and tutoring restavek kids. the strain and turmoil my friends experienced just trying to reach out to these kids was immense. neither of them lasted through their "terms" - left early.
as T&T write, once you see one, you see many.
i would really encourage anyone so moved to look into supporting MCC. they do excellent work (and no, I didn't work for them!) also, Jean Robert Cadet wrote an inspirational memoir about his experience growing up as a restavek in Haiti.
I think your blog is really interesting ... especially this post :)
T & T,
Look at this. You've already done so much for your new friend, even if it feels so helpless. Prayers are coming for her from around the world, she is seeing love in Paige and the rest of your family, and you're educating so many with your blog posts. You are an inspiration and a blessing to me. Thank you. I love having this information so I can share it.
Peace,
Heather
It's hard to even have words to respond to this situation. Is there anything WE can do besides pray for you guys in this situation?
This is just so sad... I wish that ALL of these children could understand that Someone DOES love them and gave His Life for them! These eyes speak volumes... so sad.
We do not think we can even consider taking her in for the short or long term without legal protection. There would need to be legal abandonment. It feels a lot like a trap. Any accusation could land Troy in prison or get us booted out of here. None of us like those risks.
You're asking what you can do --
I would read the links on this post, one of them is a couple that works with the MCC (as Tricia mentioned) -- check that organization out. Read the book written by a former Restavek, it is good - and eye opening.
It is pretty tough (if not impossible?) to change culture ... the force of cultural norms is ginormous. God alone can redeem it - but I don't know what that looks like or when. If you saw the Nightline special you know that there is a different mentality when it comes to these children.
The man that Nehemie lives with has no eyeballs and only like two of ten fingers ... he got that way due to the crowds he once ran with -- all of that is to say, he is a very rough guy -- I guess praying for him is a good idea too - his name is Gorge (40 yrs old?) - he and his mom (maybe 65 yrs old) have Nehemie and like 6 other children. We are not certain if any of these kids are his or if they are just "caring" for them. When you ask questions of them, the answers are pretty canned/guarded -- they know we (western culture) find it unacceptable.
Nehemie seems to be the least valued - for lack of a better way to put it. When Paige walked her home last week the lady looked at the pictures that Nehemie colored and said "Oh, maybe she is not as stupid as we think she is."
It is horrible. I find myself compartmentalizing and not thinking about it for days because thinking about it leaves me feeling so helpless and frustrated and angry.
Tara and Paige,
I praise GOD for you. I have Esther on my mind today (getting ready to do a study on her) but I couldn't help but think that you were placed in this moment with this beautiful child for such a time as this. What amazing things you can do -- just in letting the world in on what goes on in Haiti, showing her love, being an example to the family that keeps her -- the list goes on and on. It hits us in the deepest places and our nature screams --DO SOMETHING! Being in Haiti now for 7 years, I know and understand everything that you are saying. I respect you so much for the patience you are showing and I know God will move in you to do His will. We so often miss what He wants us to do when everything in us is screaming. May God bless you both and give you His peace through this.
Heather
The whole restavek system is one of the things I cannot stomach about Haiti. I have a very hard time with anyone with a little money who then abuses there blessing. I cannot fathom how someone can treat a child like trash, and then turn around and pray arms opened wide... ugh.
WOW and WOW! There are certainly no easy answers and as I read the post I was thinking all the things you have said - sounds like a set up, they could come back and sue, they could bring false charges etc etc. I am thankful for you guys and for Paige. I am thankful that for moments in time she has someone telling her she has value. I am thankful that we know her name, that she is not faceless and forgotten, and that she will be prayed over. I am thankful for your hearts. I am thankful that God has a plan, and thankful that you guys (if recent memory serves) are pretty darn good at listening and discerning!
Hurting with you (though probably not as much as you) and praying over you,
Heather
There is so much about Haiti that breaks my heart. It's hard to go through the day without weighing how much good you're doing vs. how much "bad" you're seeing. I remember asking Beth how she gets through living there without breaking down daily. It reminds me of the story of the man on the beach. Another man saw him throwing starfish back into the ocean. He asked "why are you doing that, there are so many starfish, what difference does it make?" As the man threw one more starfish into the ocean (saving it), he said "it made a difference to that one".
Keep tossing those starfish (yes, I know I'm cheesy). It's heartbreaking, but everything you do matters to someone.
God bless you.
Thank you for sharing this story. One of our children from Ghana was being raised in a similar situation ... as household help. So very sad!
I will pray for you ask you minister, for wisdom, guidance, peace, and the knowledge that you are doing all that you can, and that you will trust HIM to do the rest.
Christmas Blessings,
Laurel :)
mama of 13
Wow, just found this article about the VERY SAME THING taking place right here in the U.S. of A.! Kids all over the world living in poverty NEED OUR PRAYERS and our voices speaking up for them in any way we can!
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20081228/ap_on_re_af/the_slave_next_door
Tara,
This post has been on my mind for days and then this morning, I saw this story from the AP:
http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/T/THE_SLAVE_NEXT_DOOR?SITE=WHIZ&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT
In posting that story I see it has a somewhat 'happy' ending, but I wonder in Haiti, are there ever 'happy' endings? What happens to these children when their 'masters' die?
This is so sad; I've been praying for your family and the role you can have in this little girls' life. Yet how hard it must be to know that you can't save them all, but like Mandi said (and it wasn't cheesy, I love that saying) all you can do is help one. Thanks for opening our eyes to another reality of Haiti.
So sad about this.
As I read your blog I broke, I had to get up from the computer and walk away. Our first two grandchildren are from Haiti. They were adopted when our daughter and her husband were there as missionaries. I cannot imagine or don't want to think about what it could have been for them. Thomas is now 11 and Taisie is 9. They are so full of life, so smart and imaginative. They were both given up by their birth parents, different families but both from Jacmel. I cannot fathom them being restaveks and not having them bright future that is open for them. I pray that you continue to have the strength and grace to minister to "the least of these". May God bless you both.
Hi Tara. I have been on an internet fast for awhile, I am so glad I found this piece from you. I cry when I read these things, and I am so grateful for you and Troy and who you are. "you really love her, don't you?" I hope is some small way I can have some impact the way you guys do. keep up the good work. again, I hope to see you sometime this year for a day or so if schedules can work out. God bless all of you. I am praying for the little girl, hoping she will find someone who loves her.
Nightline did a 10-15 min piece on restaveks 2 nights ago. Awesome to get info out there, raise awareness.
I know some former restaveks... even had the honor of helping one learn how to read. God is faithful, in a painfully broken, ugly world.
Post a Comment