
In the last few months there has been a major road project going through the center of the country. Because of this new road we did not have to walk six hours to get to Renald's house. We were able to drive about 70 minutes and then walk the last two miles into the area where his home is. The road is really an amazing thing, a huge, huge undertaking. Seeing the giant earth moving equipment right along side people who've lived a very simple life for decades and decades seemed quite odd. In the photo below you can see the road winding behind us. Before the hurricanes came through last fall this road did not exist. All of the travel to the area we were heading was by foot or donkey.

We've been in the mountains of Haiti before, but it has been a long time. I think we forgot. The views were breathtaking. More than once there were tears streaming down our faces as we took in such vast and overwhelming beauty. Photos of what we were seeing will never do it justice, the clouds were sometimes below us and the mountains went on for as far as the eye could see. For the entire ride I just kept thinking, this is too beautiful to be real.
Renald seemed nervous and off his game a bit. He is fairly verbal but he was not talking on the ride up. The two photos below are right before we started the walking portion of our trip. We walked straight down steep mountains and back up again to reach his home which is located a long way off of the new road. In the second photo Paige is looking toward his house, where our walk would take us.
About 1/3 of the way into our half hour trek we ran into a guy who said he was "with the mother of the child". Renald showed no recognition but went to him when the man reached for him. My heart sunk learning that there was a guy in the picture. So often the new guy does not want the previous guy's kids. That story has been told over and over again in Haiti.
As we got closer to the area where their house is located Renald asked for Paige and switched to her arms. He seemed to know where he was. He also seemed concerned (that is how we read it anyway) and maybe a little bit nervous. 
While the next 15 minutes were not what I prayed or hoped for, I am trying to be objective. I am not Haitian and I do not express emotion like a Haitian. It is unfair for me to expect them to jump up and down and hug their child and cry for joy and do what I think I would do ... that might not be a response that happens in this culture.
Renald was not very happy, while he seemed to remember them he tightened his grip on Paige. His Mom smiled at him as we walked up but when he did not want to go to her she was put off and seemed hurt and upset with him. 
The boyfriend is not Renald's father and was telling Troy and Frank (a long-time employee from RHFH/Cazale that escorted us) that he was really kind of thinking we would just keep Renald. The boyfriend was the low point in the whole situation. The Mom never said anything like that.
In situations like theirs it is possible that a healthy kid that is used to eating three meals a day might be an overwhelming thing for them. Not only another mouth to feed, but a child who won't be happy with one tiny meal a day.
Renald cried softly for most of the time we stood trying to talk to them. A crowd of relatives gathered.
The brightest moment was when Renald's Granny realized he was back. She was genuinely happy and pleased to see him healthy. He did better going to Gran than he did going to his Mom.


Troy asked a lot of questions about the other kids and how old they were. It was sad when the Mom could not remember the name of the 18 month old baby. She came up with it about 30 seconds later. I don't know if survival mode makes names unimportant or if possibly prolonged malnutrition or other factors play into things. It did seem like the Mom was struggling to take in the information and answer questions. She may have been totally overwhelmed by all the attention. I have no way of understanding her life... Simply no way at all.
Beth asked me if I thought it was universal to love your child and if possibly the privilege of wealth allows us greater freedom to love. I don't know the answer. Maybe so.
Below are two older siblings of Renald and also his little brother, who is the child of the boyfriend we met. They are standing in front of the house they all live in. None of them look all that healthy, but none of them look as sick or as malnourished as Renald did back in June. The sister is 8 and the older brother is 6.



While everything in us (Paige and I) wanted to just take him and run, we know we needed to give them their son, brother, grandson back. He is not ours to take from them. I think we want to believe that we love him more -- but there is no way we can know that. That is our egotistical judgment.The reactions were not what we wanted but we cannot know their hearts. Renald needs time to bond to them and we were dumb to think he would be instantly happy to be home. Because I can provide a nicer house, toys and food -- it does not mean that I am a better person to raise him. I value those things, you value those things ... but plenty of people live their lives without those things and they live long, happy lives.
I waited a day to write because I was angry and upset and I know I needed to step back and calm down. I instantly decided that they don't love him as much as we do ... and that was wrong of me. I do not know that.
The truth is, all of us (some of you included) fell hard for this beautiful little boy. Renald needed healing and God gave him that. He gets to start over without worms and fevers and illness. He touched our lives with his fight to live and his beautiful smiling eyes and crazy fun dance moves.
I have to believe that Renald is not done touching lives. Not by any stretch of the imagination. To think that this little boy from a tiny shack in the remote mountains of Haiti has been seen, prayed for, and loved by hundreds and hundreds of people from all over the world is mind-numbing.
I hope you'll continue to love and pray for him.
We prayed with his Mom, hugged him goodbye, and left with heavy grief and blurry-eyes.
There are plans in place to help them with food, etc. We are not leaving them hanging. It is a tricky thing because we want to do our best to make sure that the kids are going to benefit from the help. Explaining why that is tricky is a whole different blog post. Renald's Mom will hopefully keep her appointment with Licia and Lori in Cazale in late November. At that time we'll be able to see how Renald is doing. For now we know we need to give this family a chance. We need to reserve our judgment and trust the same God we trusted for Renald's healing.The peace we were longing for has yet to settle in on us, but we wait in hopeful expectation.
These last photos were taken after we hiked back out. They overlook the absolute beauty of the Artibonite Valley.
Troy griped at us for not smiling so we rallied at the end.
A GIANT amount of love and respect goes out to Licia and Lori and Big Zach. They do the hard work of helping children heal and then watching them leave ... only they do it all the time. We could not have gone up the mountain in our truck, Zach was gracious to us and took us up in his truck. He loved us and cheered us on and showed us the beautiful sights. Thank you for everything Zach. We love you so much.
Until later,Tara for all of us
51 comments:
well. that was a journey. When you said all of us fell hard for Renald, I thought, yes i did. It is when i noticed whole heartedly what you are involved with there. I don't know what else to say at this time. Other than I'm so grateful for you all there and what you do. I never thought of you sending them back. I wonder why? But that adds something more to what you do.
bless you.
Jeff
Wow! This is a wonderful post. I especially liked your words "Beth asked me if I thought it was universal to love your child and if possibly the privilege of wealth allows us greater freedom to love." I've done third world country stuff and I work with poor kids as a teacher in the US. It is very easy to try to package your version of love as the only kind of love that exists. And somehow poverty does seem to effect how love manifests itself. Really true on a lot of levels.
As an adoptive mom, I also loved the portion on not believing I love better. It is hard not to feel that way, hard not to glibbly feel that my child has a better life because they live with me. It sometimes feel like you are caught in between seeing the reality which logically leads you to believe that is true and then recognizing how awful shallow it makes you seem if you believe that your privelege as a US citizen automatically makes you a better mom.
I may have to link to this post sometime. It just sums up a lot for me.
Caught in the unfairness of it all, wishing that sometimes life were fair.
praying and trusting. thank you for being the hands and feet. thank you for your love and involvement in the messy business of life and relationships. thanks for sharing.
Praying.
I can't imagine what you are feeling. The pictures and story make my heart so heavy for little Renald. I'll be praying for him and his whole family...and for you too (especially Paige).
In Christ,
Julie
Does wealth provide us greater freedom to love? I don't know. But I do know that poverty breaks family--every time--everywhere.
I have my issues with "Western" culture, but one thing we bring with us is this "luxury" of family. I pray that you not only brought a boy back to his family, but also began to teach that family how to love.
Oh Tara and Paige! I've been there. Your journey brought back some of my own grief tonight. I've made those journeys to return a child to their family in Haiti after loving on them for months. Knowing God had asked me to love that child for that time. M'ap priye pou nou-menm aswe-a.
Amazing post. You bring tears to my eyes to imagine what it is like, the fact that you felt so much love for Renald but also see (even if you and us do not want to) that you could provide a 'better' life for him than his birth family. To be big enough, faithful enough, to give them a chance...you are all amazing, serving an amazing Lord.
Love Always,
LeAnne
beautifully written. what a hard reality but thanks for reminding us of a God that is greater than we can imagine and realizing Renalds families love, even if it looks different than ours.
Paige,
My heart is aching for you and with you.
You loved little Renald like your own child and then let him go.
I pray you will have comfort and healing for your heart. And also the courage to do more hard things with great love... even when it hurts.
You are an amazing person, doing God's work with your hands. No one could ask more of anyone.
~Carol C
Amazingly sad and beautiful all at the same time. I sit here unable to really process it all and yet you and your family lived it.
We have no way to understand their life, their love, their survival. Yet, that has not stopped you from trying to reach in and love practically, deeply and sacrificially. Beautiful. Simply beautiful.
I will pray for Renald, his family and for yours.
Shalom,
Denise
My heart ached when I read this post. You captured the reality of the struggle in such a way with your words and photographs. May the Lord bless "Rey" with joy and love and health, and may He comfort and encourage your family as you faithfully walk where He leads.
Crying here. I totally understood how you saw the reaction of the mother and the boyfriend. We saw that too often when we lived there. It's so hard to understand when we don't live like they do. God bless your family for putting yourselves in this place. I know it was hard.
Tears and prayers!
Tara, this post is amazing. You've expressed the ambiguities so beautifully. It was wrenching to read but "I have to believe that Renald is not done touching lives. Not by any stretch of the imagination." Believing with you for that.
Awesome post, Tara.
Lindsey and I have thought and prayed for your family over the past couple of days.
Tears are streaming down my face as I write this...I, too, have been touched by Renald and hope that I will be a better person by 'knowing' him. I am amazed and awed by Paige's grace - what a wonderful child you have raised! Sendings prayers to the Livesay family and Renald.
No words.
I love you, Livesay's.
Wow.
Love to you all, and prayers.
ugh, a hard, a hard post, a hard life.
SV
Heavy hearted with you, and praying for him and his family.
You've described this well and brought up so many points that I have never thought of before. My tendency is to disrespect them because they have no way to provide for him, you've called me on that. I was one of the people who felt like you should have just kept him, but now I see your point.
I guess I want to thank you for your courage to do what is right even though it hurt a lot. I will be praying for all of you in the mountains and in PortauPrince.
Sometimes we think we are exhibiting great faith in circumstances that ultimately, we can control, manipulate, process. No. THIS...utterly helpless release with a complete lack of understanding...this is the depth of sincere faith.
I stand in awe of you and am destroyed with you and love you so much!
Wow. Many tears. Praying for you guys and for Renald. He truly has touched so many people's lives. Thanks for all you did for him!
Thanks for sharing. No other words. Praying for y'all.
amy(TN)
Oh dear God. I could barely read the last half of the post because I was crying so hard. The strength that it took for you guys to do that.... seriously, it is totally overwhelming. I am completely at a loss for what to say. So I will just tell you, yet again, how much I appreciate your blogging, how much I respect what you are doing, and how much we are keeping you in our thoughts and prayers everyday and hoping to do more to support you in the future. Incredibly intense story. Thank you for doing and thank you for sharing a bit of what you're doing with those of us reading.
Praying for you all -- that you will find that peace that surpasses all understanding,
Heather
What a beautiful post and story. Wow. I completely know how this felt. Its so hard!I don't know that I could have found the strength inside me to go to the home and see things first hand. I guess I appreciate the small amount of denial that I live in for the babies that we have been blessed to have as a part of our lives from Haiti- even for just a short few months. You have done well Livesays. We love ya!
Forever prayers for Renald and his families- both of them. :)
I cannot imagine how difficult your journey to love and let go of precious Renald. I would struggle to think that I love more; I know I would. And I appreciate your expressions about our ease at standing high in judgement because of our wealth. How can we know? relate? judge?
Bless you. I'm praying for you all and for Renald and his family.
I love this...thank you so much for sharing. How is Paige doing with it all?
It's not OK that there is poverty in the world that can even take away a person's right to love and care for their kids. I thank God for the work you (and He) are doing to give this little man his chance.
Even though we have adopted from Haiti... I learned the most when we hosted the two little girls from Haiti in our home for two months...
I learned that family does not look the same everywhere... and that does not make one way better than the other.
I learned that I certainly like things done a particular way- but that does not make it the "right" or only way.
I also learned that "providing" for a child is different in different cultures... as Americans we way overdo it on what we think our children "need".
I think more than nourishing Renald's body, you nourished his soul... you gave him a chance to be silly, and to have fun. You gave him extra attention that he might have never received otherwise... THOSE gifts will be with him forever! And prayerfully he will be able to share those gifts with his siblings.
loving and letting go bites the big one EVERY TIME...
We love you guys... we will continue to pray for Renald's family... and for you as you continue this adventure.
Thanks for taking away some of my anger Tara. I too have a rock on my chest. Getting to know you and your family and the work that World Wide Village is involved in has been a huge blessing for me. Thank you for sharing everything so honestly and openly with all of us. We don't all have the opportunites to be there and this brings it all so much closer for me. Prayers for all of you and Renald and family.
Your wisdom totally blesses me.
Thanks for posting about the tough stuff. You made some wonderful points about what love looks like. I have wondered often if my ability to provide stuff makes me any better at loving my kids. We cannot relate to the decisions these moms have to make.
I am so blessed by you and your family. God is using you in mighty ways to touch so many lives.
Renald does have a mighty army of warriors praying for him and his family. Those prayers will not go unheard. Thanks for sharing the results, we are all praying for you too.
Sometimes as I pass through the streets of Haiti I have great pains in my stomach because as a mother I cannot help but put myself in their place. What would it be like to be pregnant in that hut that leaks? What would it be like to lay my babies down on that floor that is covered with dirt and bugs and worms. What would it be like not to have a choice? What would I be ok with just to know my baby is asleep on a bed with clean sheets and a full tummy? Beth is right in everyway.
I loved this post so much. It showed the truthful pain of what many missionaries go through and the absolute truth of the Haitian family. God bless you for what you did for Renald. He will remember your love for the rest of his life.
Oh.my.gosh. Beautifully told, Tara.
And what a reality check for me. Thanks for your love and care for the people of Haiti.
((Hugs))
Thank you sincerely for sharing this painful story, and for helping your readers understand the deep complexity of this issue. I am really moved by your desire to help us all understand this. Thank you not just for making this part of the emotional work you are doing here.
If I may, I'd like to share something I learned living in Haiti.
I was also confused as to why parents didn't always know the names of their little ones, it bothered me, until it was explained to me that because so many children under 5 die, it's not common for kids to get named until they've "survived" a few years.
There's a birth certificate name, but it's not always "kijan w rele" it's not always "what you're called"... rarely do you hear "ki nom w genyen" what's your name, because a child is not always given a name. Often they "grow" into their name. Some consider it "tempting fate" to name a baby.
It helped me in a way when I learned that and I just thought I would share it.
thinking of your family during these hard times.
Tara,
Do you realize what a wonderful gift you have, to do with your words what Troy does with the camera lens? You all are so beautifully balanced in your talents.
Your words and Troy's photos are absolutely amazing.
Praying for you all, Renald, and Paige. This post brought tears to my eyes and gave me a lot to think about on many different angles. Ouch.
Paige Dooly
I cried for all of you when I read you account of returning such a precious child to his family. I hope you will keep in contact with him and make sure he is ok. I thought of Renald today as I went through my daily routines and wondered what was going on in that little head of his. I thought of Paige too - it must be so hard.
Regards, Elizabeth
In my own selfishness and American way of thinking I could not have given him back. In my selfishness I believe you provided him with more love and a better home. BUT we must trust God to make the call. Well done, good and faithful servants.
I've been a mostly quiet follower of the blog for about a year now. This post told a powerful story. I am in tears. Thank you for sharing and I will be praying for you all.
The look on that little guys face - it breaks my heart. I am so sorry. I hope you can tell a somewhat happy ending to this at some point.
I am thinking about all of you and Renald.
I have been out of town all week and this was the first chance I had to see all of this. Renald is an amazing kid and an awesome story. We will continue to pray for him and his family, as well as his family for a time.
Thank you Paige for all you do. I could only hope my kids exhibit the compassion and strength that you have shown in Renald over these last few months. Through the pain you will be stronger and closer to our amazing God who has orchestrated all of these event.
Love you all!
Nate
Wow. We serve a BIG God. Our hope is in Him. Love and prayers from us to you.
You guys give me joy and make me hopeful. Here in this affluent area of Southern California, I am mildly angry on a daily basis at the privileged, overly-anxious moms and children with whom my son attends school. Play-dates, Meet and Greets, Golf-tournament fundraisers--sheesh.
I love that Beth M. even ponders the question of child-parent relationships. My gut says that we our expectations of the role of parents ARE founded on our material wealth in the U.S. The more we have, the more we have to give our children, who learn there is no purpose for them other than to receive. Has there ever been heartfelt altruism, discovery, or goodness to come from a child of wealth. No. There is only destruction--of the self and the soul.
Little Renald... may he live a life where he receives exactly what he needs--no more and no less.
I have been very touched by the story of this little boy...it is not an easy one...thank you for sharing it...
I read this Wednesday and have not stopped thinking about Renald since then. You made me think about the way I perceive the poor. Thank you.
How not to cry reading you and looking at your wonderful pics ?
Your faith is huge, I admire you to be so confident in God's love.
I'll always remember little Renald. I wish you to hear from him and his family at the end of the month.
Thank you so much for what you do.
Cécile from France
What you are feeling and experiencing every foster parent experiences here in the states as well. You gave Renald the one thing he needs most, his family. Through his family he will have strength of spirit. His Mom's boyfriend is being real. I am sure he is thinking, "Give him a chance. Send him to the white family where he can survive, go to school, have a chance." He was probably thinking what will he do here? It may not be because he didn't want him... but wanted a better life for him.
But you did the right thing to give him what he needs most. His people, his family, his roots. Just as foster parents have to send kids home to the hands of those that have abused them, they also know they are their family and for a child that means the world.
The picture of Granny and he is amazing. He will adjust, he is strong. He will succeed despite the odds you saw. Your love enabled him to live and survive. Bless you and your family for what you have done!
Prayers abound!
Because I can provide a nicer house, toys and food -- it does not mean that I am a better person to raise him.
I have to admit, I just don't get it. So although you may be able to provide him with food, you're not a better person to raise him? Seriously?
Hi Jules -
I guess it is just a realization that most of the world is poor ... and they love their children - they just were not blessed to be born into the situation that Troy and I were. I was sort of wrestling with the desire to remove Renald from his family (and I could easily talk them into that - but it would not make it right) and just expressing my thoughts that being "rich" does not make me a better mom than a "poor" mom. I think anytime a family can stay in tact ... that is best. And I say that as an adoptive mom of three.
Post a Comment