Friday, October 23, 2009

Transracial Adoption

In the fall of 2001 we made a decision to adopt internationally. We had our own personal reasons for choosing to leave the USA to build our family.

We followed our hearts and felt strongly that our hearts were aligned with His and moved forward without too much consideration about being a white family raising black kids. To our discredit we did not fully research or understand the challenges of transracial adoption. Sometimes ignorance really is bliss. Thankfully, that bliss of ignorance can only last so long ... then you learn something.

I remember people questioning us about raising Hope and Isaac in a 99% white suburb, and not really agreeing with them that it might be difficult. (And now, many years later I simply think that there will be challenges either way- just different ones in different locations.)

Ike and Hope have been with us for almost 7 years. In that time we've encountered some hurtful things, some funny things, and some totally ignorant people, and some really encouraging people. We've have been hurt by harsh words but we've also had multiple positive conversations. We've learned a lot about what we didn't know when we first sought to adopt cross-culturally and transracially. We've grown more sensitive to the way we speak about adoption, families, birth-parents, and certainly the language we use when we make observations about ourselves or other blended families. We've tried to offer grace to people who just don't get it.

Moving to Haiti has not removed the challenges for Hope and Isaac - it has simply created new ones. In MN they were the minority and stood out as such. In Haiti they are the majority and we (their parents) stand out, therefore they do too. It may be harder for them here. They don't escape being "different". Now they are "those kids that live with the blans" to our neighbors. In many ways moving here just made us all odd outsiders and it is no longer a unique thing that only Hope and Isaac experience.

Truth be told, I probably worry more about Isaac than the girls. It does not take an anthropologist to figure out that many folks have already made their decisions about young black men. No longer can Isaac escape prejudice by being "that cute little black boy" - he's getting to the age (and size) where he'll likely begin to notice less automatic acceptance from some people.

As parents, we place a ton of faith in the power of love - and we trust and look to God for direction when situations arise. We strive to make sure our children know beyond any doubt that there is one place in this world where they will always belong and are so special they cannot be replaced. That place is here in this family. We're not so ignorant to think that we can protect them from all hurt and painful things -- we just hope to provide cushioning and encouragement when the punches land. And while adoption is a positive thing to them right now, we're prepared that at times in their life they may not feel that way.

When we went to Minnesota we had an interesting experience at immigration in Miami. As the five of us (T and T, Paige, Isaac and Noah) stepped forward and handed the officer our passports, the officer said in a terse voice, "Who is he with?" Troy and I were standing behind the three kids but Troy's response was to turn and look over his shoulder behind us to see if someone else had stepped forward to the window with us.

Troy looked back to the officer confused and the officer said, "This guy here", pointing at Isaac. (The officer had five U.S. passports in his hand already.) Troy said, "He is our son, he is with us."

The officer said, "Where are his adoption papers?" Troy said, "He is a U.S. Citizen and you have his U.S. passport in that stack." The officer went on to question when we adopted him, etc. He did not bother to look at the passport to see Isaac has been in and out of the country plenty of times.

Troy answered the questions, Isaac stood listening and Paige and I were just shocked by how cruddy the agent was at human-interaction. As he finally started to scan our passports he looks at Isaac and says, "Who are these people?" while gesturing toward us. Isaac looked at the guy and then glanced at us with a questioning look and said, "my parents!" (like, what is this guy thinking? duh.)

The whole thing annoyed me not because I expect a immigration officer to be adoption savvy or sensitive -- but because I expect an immigration officer to look at the passport he was handed and use his brilliant mind to do a little-tiny bit of detective work.

After we walked away to go grab our luggage I said, "How are you Ike - are you okay honey? Are you feeling alright about things?" I was all prepared to do damage control and counseling.

Isaac said, "Yeah, I just wish I could stop sneezing so much!" :)

As we approach the 7th anniversary of our adoption day next week, I am so grateful for our family and the way God put it together. I am thankful for opportunities to learn and grow. I am good with being different and as a family we celebrate the many things that make our family "weird" to others. Isaac and Hope are a gift to us and everyone who knows them. We thank the Lord for entrusting us with this awesome responsibility.

May we be equal to the task He has given us.

(2002)

19 comments:

HMK said...

Wow, I'm really blown away by the immigration officer. I'm almost speechless but I know stuff like this does and can and will happen. Sigh.

Amanda said...

First off...well written. Your kiddos are beautiful and obviously loved.

But I gotta say, you just made SMOKE roll outta my ears. I'm ready to go PUMMEL some immigration officer...and I'm sure he won't be hard to find because he'll have MORON written across his forehead.

Oh. Oi. Did I just type that??? temporary loss of graciousness....sorry.

Seriously, though, this is just one of a plethora of examples that I've seen recently where our society is clearly going backwards in professionalism and service. Sheesh.

Signe said...

Okay I can now go delete my post on this subject and just direct folks here. I was thinking many of these very same things, but of course, you said it so much better. I love being one of those weird families that just bring on so mnay remarks. We have almost gotten to the point that people don't even know which rude comment to make anymore. It is good to know that there are really wonderful people out there that totally get it.

God Bless You all.

stephanie garcia said...

Great post. I like to think that being a missionaries in a cross-cultural context does level the playing field by making every member of this family a little "weird" to those outside looking in ... you described it so well. :)

Mike and Katie said...

Blessings to your family. We share your heart and appreciate the perspective. All we can do is pray we do the best with the opportunities God has provided us with.

Chelsea said...

I have heard similar stories recently about airport security from other adoptive families. It is crazy how ignorant people pretend to be. I am sorry that your family (especially Isaac!) had to experience that.

How old were Isaac & Hope when you adopted them? I am assuming that Hope was a baby judging by the picture :). Was adopting from Haiti a much quicker process when you adopted your children? I know that now it takes years and years. Also, I was wondering if you are fostering Annie (your niece)? I know she is waiting to go home to America but I was just wondering how it works in Haiti, that she is living with you while waiting... Sorry if my questions are too personal. I really have felt drawn to Haiti and would love to volunteer there in the future.
Thanks!
Chelsea

shirley said...

Beautifully written. I hope everyone in the greater Smith-
Terwilleger clan has a chance to read your insights.

Leslie said...

You said so many of the things that roll around in my head with adopting and living here at the same time. I wonder what things O is going to have to hear and process about being a Haitian adopted by "blans". And how will things be for her if/when we have another baby? So many questions and no answers right now.

The Immigration thing makes me angry. Have you considered writing a letter to someone about the situation? I know it may feel like that won't do any good but you never know. The bottom line is that THAT, is not appropriate on any level, especially not right in front of your kid. There needs to be some education done there. One time I went through and was asked what I was doing in Haiti and I replied that I worked for an NGO (non-government org.) and the imm. officer looked at me and said, "What's an NGO?" Um, what? I guess I just expected that as a GOVERNMENT employee that question would never come up.

T & T Livesay said...

In 2002 adoptions in Haiti took 6-9 months. Our children came home in 7 months. Hope was not yet a year old. Ike had turned one.

Anonymous said...

Great post. Worth directing people too. sometimes other people just say your thoughts better than you do.

We are going to be raising a "Black man in America" too--whenever our haitian adoption is finished! A comedian made a joke about adopting a black child and how cute they are until they become about 11 or 12 and get "scary"(or something like that)...we were like "gulp. crap. that's our son." First instinct is to fight all of those thoughts from others, but then that is near impossible. So, we are back to dealing with what we can control.

As you, we probably haven't thought of everything..but hope grace and love lead us through.
thanks for the insight and example.
Cathleen

Anonymous said...

I'm with you, friend. Raising my multi racial family is not always easy, but there is no better place than the center of God's will, and I know that I know that I know I followed His will to bring home my kids.

Had dinner with John last night. Ask him about his onion soda when you see him again...*grin*

Meri

Sophia said...

I wish I was a little bit more surprised by the actions of that Miami immigration officer....

I think your family is wonderful!!! There are many challenges in your situation but I think with the mind set that you have, you will get through all of them.

e-Mom said...

Hope and Isaac both have incredible love and joy in their eyes... but especially Isaac. He seems relaxed and accepting of life and people (high EQ) and I think, in the grand scheme of his life, he'll do just fine.

Maybe he'll end up an international diplomat like Colin Powell. He'll be able to use his exposure to two cultures as an advantage--and to benefit others.

You're a sensitive but very strong Mom.

(((Hugs)))

Nate and Brenda said...

Internationally adopted kids deal with these issues all the time. Not even our Russian kids are treated differently occasionally. They are perceived by some people as "different". We have made it our responsibility to educate people who are considering int. adoption on the issues they will face as it does not seem adoption agencies want to deal with it.
Good post Tara. Amen.
Nate

Anonymous said...

Thanks for keeping your blog real by posting on topics that adoptive parents can learn from. Like others, we are waiting for our sibling set from Haiti, but it takes quite a bit longer now. Reading others' experiences helps prepare us and make the wait go faster.

Jon and Lori

Heather said...

Superb post!!!

Kim and Patrick Bentrott said...

Thank you for posting this. As our own "multi-cultural" family takes shape, we are constantly delving into "where is the best place for him to grow up?' I guess the truth is, in our home... where ever that may be, in love. I wish we could protect our children (and others) from the world sometimes. But i have to say, I loved how Isaac let that creepy interaction roll off his shoulders. Bravo.

Your beautiful family is an inspiration as we start ours. And I"m glad to know you--if only over the internet thus far--to have the support of such shared experiences as Haiti, raising a family, and tackling the challenges along the way.

Thanks. :)

The Millenders said...

Thank God you're weirdos - this blog would be SO boring without it! How is Isaac's sneezing doing now? I can't believe none of these insensitive commenters have asked!

Praying for grace for your family every day. Praying for Rey today. Much love from Africa.

The Ellis' said...

Thanks for sharing your life on here. It's encouraging!